Another concert at the Usher Hall tonight – Scottish Chamber Orchestra conducted by Wayne Marshall playing a programme of Gershwin, Bernstein and Copland. And more Gershwin.
They started with Rhapsody In Blue, Marshall directing from the piano. It was very – well, bluesy. In the piano parts, Marshall seemed to be improvising a fair bit (I’ve no idea if that’s in the score or not), and it was great. He seemed to take a very flexible approach to the tempo, and it worked really well. It’s rare that classical orchestras swing, but SCO was really up for it. The opening clarinet meet me smile, and I kept smiling throughout. An excellent performance.
The Bernstein was new to me and most of the audience too – Marshall had to tell us to clap at the end because no one was sure if it was over: it was a very episodic piece, Fancy Free, based on a ballet score. It was very dynamic – there were quite moments when it reminded me of Copland’s Quiet City. The actual Copland piece was El Salón México. Not a piece I know, somewhat lighter than other pieces.
The second Gershwin piece was a symphonic arrangement of Porgy And Bess. As far as I’m concerned, the definitive version is Gil Evans’ arrangement for Miles Davis – music I want played at my funeral. (Not all of it!). I have a couple of other jazz versions, too, and I’ve heard the opera (on CD conducted by Rattle and also on the radio, I think). The opera was really disappointing – overly long and portentous. Whereas Gil Evans said it all in forty minutes.
This arrangement was by Robert Russell Bennett, a contemporary and occasional assistant of Gershwin’s (thank you, Google), in 1942. It worked really well. All the tunes were there (nearly) and it flowed from one theme to another. I had to stop myself singing along at places (Summertime and Ain’t Necessarily So…).
It was Marshall and the SCO that made it of course: the orchestra really seemed to be into it. At one point I thought the tympanist was going to start dancing around her drums. All the percussionists were good; actually, the whole orchestra was good. It just felt right.
For an encore, Marshall played an improvisation around I Got Rhythm on the impressive organ. In all the times I’ve been to the Usher Hall, I don’t remember hearing the organ played. Maybe in a Bruckner or Mahler symphony? This was a fun coda to the evening. Who could ask for anything more?